Vladimir Vasilyevich Markovnikov was a Russian organic chemist who worked in the mid 1800’s. During his research working with halides and alkenes, he was looking for any similarities between all of the different reactions. He noticed a common occurrence that some reactions yielded only one product when they were thought to be able to yield more than one possible product. After examining the reaction more closely, it was noticed that the halide in the only product was bonded to the carbon with a higher degree of substitution. Therefore, the halide would be bonded to, for example, a tertiary carbon rather than a primary or secondary carbon. This and later research led to the formation of the Markovnikov rule, which was widely accepted in the world of organic chemistry. This rule states that in the addition of HX, X being a halide such as bromine and chlorine (excluding fluorine and iodine), to an alkene, the more highly substituted carbocation is formed as the intermediate rather than the less highly substituted one.
Markovnikov wasn’t the only one to notice the absence of a product after predicting more would occur. This has been a common dilemma for many other researchers as well, including George Kimball and Irving Roberts who conducted research in 1937. During Kimball and Robert’s research with bromine gas and chlorine gas additions to alkenes, they observed only one product, which led them to question why this occurred. The answer to this, they proposed, was instead of the intermediate being a carbocation, like one would normally predict, the intermediate was a bromonium ion or a chloronium ion. These ions would form from a nucleophilic attack from bromine or chlorine. The formation of the ion results in anti-stereochemistry, which is observed in reactions of cycloalkenes with halides. Rather than both a cis and trans product, only trans product was formed. This is because once there’s a bromonium ion on one side of the cycloalkane; the other negatively charged bromine will attack from the opposite side since the large bromine is shielding one whole side.
Alkene oxymercuration is closely analogous to halohydrin formation. The reaction is initiated by electrophilic addition of Hg2+ ion to the alkene to give an intermediate mercurium ion, whose structure resembles that of a bromonium ion. Nucleophilic addition of water as in halohydrin formation, followed by deprotonation, then yields a stable organomercury product.